What Would You Choose?

So Greg's latest deep thought, prompted by the forest fires, was if I would rather my house burn down (aka loose all my earthly possessions) or lose my dogs. I quickly answered save my dogs... Greg looked at me like I was crazy. And then sent me off on a mission to poll my school friends who agreed with me; Greg's coworkers all agreed with him.
Maybe once you have a job and have worked hard and have kids the answer is different? I still say it depends on the relationship you have with your dogs. And when my house burns down I'm planning on insurance replacing everything - it would be different if I would be destitute and living on the street I guess. Everything in my house except pictures practically could be bought again and I would have a lot less stuff to worry about hauling around from house to house that I can't bear to throw away now - a fire might be a blessing in disguise. Greg even told me that dogs are earthly possessions! Does this look like morning cuddle time of a guy who believes such a thing?

Any input? I like to think Greg's the one in the wrong and not me - isn't that only logical?